Allstars discussion

[Shir]

Thoughts?!


We had some amazing characters this season. People in the running this season for me are:

Sofia
Mike
Sam
Brittany
Neda
Zach


But that's one person too many.


Sofia is likely taking Sam to the finals, so I feel like him being in the F2 should give him an auto ticket to AS. Not to mention, he was involved in two alliances and big drama in the house.

I feel strongly about Sofia, Mike and Brittany making it into AS as well. IDK what you guys think of that?

This leaves Neda and Zach. 

[Jade]

I agree with your four picks. If it's between neda and Zach, I say Zach because he was more of a player then neda. Neda started out strong for the first few rounds then She flew behind Zachs shadows. If you want neda in as well then I say, take out mike. I think it's between those two for me

[Rhian Sugden]

Sam was dull, but he played a big role in the game and if he makes F2, I think he deserves to play again. Sofia, without question. I loved her from start to finish. Mike was an underdog and I feel like he had a great story. Brittany was the sweetheart and I would love, love to see her play again now that she's gotten her feet wet. If it's between Zach and Neda, I think we all know I'm gonna' say Zach. Despite our little spat earlier, he played a better game than Neda and could've gone far and even won had he not been stopped when he was. For me, it's more between Mike and Neda. Mike getting the edge because of his endurance skills.

[Shir]

Ok thanks guys!

Yeah, i feel the same about Zach vs Neda. But I also feel like mike had a great story, so if it were my vote alone, it would be Sofia, Sam, Brittany, Mike and Zach.

[James Rhine]

Sofia and Brittany should be fo shos 100%. I'd throw in Zach and Sam but I'm not sure about Mike after seeing his performance in Part 3. While his story is alright, he really didn't know much of what was going on. I say throw Brian in there for shits and giggles

[Shir]

No

[Kat]

I think all of UN should make AS and Brittany. Mike is a great underdog though

[James Rhine]

I kid, I kid about Brian lol. I say Neda over Mike. Poor Brian lmao, so much hate

[test]

Godney still don't know who brain is? Who brain fart?

[Shir]

I find this really difficult because I really believe Mike earned his spot in AS. I loved the UN at the time, but when Zach revealed his first alliance to them, It went downhill. As soon as they became official, it sunk. I don't think they did anything as an alliance.

[Jade]

Oct 30, 2014 7:27:25 GMT -5 Shir said:

I find this really difficult because I really believe Mike earned his spot in AS. I loved the UN at the time, but when Zach revealed his first alliance to them, It went downhill. As soon as they became official, it sunk. I don't think they did anything as an alliance.

i agree with that. It was basically Zach and Sam working both sides, Sofia doing her own thing and neda being Zachs bitch

[Memphis Garrett]

Sofia
Brittany
Sam
Mike
Zach

with Neda as a replacement. I was trying to pick between her and Zach and I feel Zach had more of a pivotal role in the game and was good in challenges. I feel like Mike definitely deserves All Stars. He was the underdog. He was a target from the very start, shut out of the original alliances and was still able to make it far. That's very impressive.

[Memphis Garrett]

Oct 30, 2014 7:27:25 GMT -5 Shir said:

I find this really difficult because I really believe Mike earned his spot in AS. I loved the UN at the time, but when Zach revealed his first alliance to them, It went downhill. As soon as they became official, it sunk. I don't think they did anything as an alliance.

I agree. The UN was nice in concept, but they didn't really execute it well and it didn't last for too long. 

[Kat]

It would suck for Mike to miss out due to the amount of effort he put in. I'm thinking like 25 hours all up in endurances lol

I guess I would be fine with him over Neda because he was a great underdog.

[Rhian Sugden]

I think Kat said UN for the reason that they basically won all the standard competitions this season, with the exception of Mike. Even though they weren't official until Week #4, they were basically together since the start based on who they favored. I do think the weakest link in the UN from my perspective, was Neda, which is why she would be up for debate in either getting in or not.